UPSC PlannerNotesFree toolsBlogPlanner
Indian Polity ยท Laxmikanth ยท Chapter 10 ยท pp. 119โ€“122

Fundamental Duties made easy

Rights come with duties. The original Constitution had only Rights. Duties were added later, in 1976.

Part IVAArticle 51A11 duties42nd Amdt 1976 โ†’ 1086th Amdt 2002 โ†’ +1From USSR

1The story in one minute

Why duties were missing, and how they came in

In simple words: Rights and duties go together. But the framers wrote only Fundamental Rights for citizens. They put the State's duties in as Directive Principles. Citizens' duties came only in 1976, and one more was added in 2002.
1950 ยท Original Constitution: Fundamental Rights only, no Fundamental Duties.
1975โ€“77 ยท Internal Emergency. The need for duties was "felt" during this time.
1976 ยท Congress Party sets up the Sardar Swaran Singh Committee. It suggests a separate chapter of duties.
1976 ยท 42nd Amendment Act adds Part IVA with only one Article, Article 51A, listing 10 duties.
1977โ€“78 ยท Janata Government (Morarji Desai) undoes many 42nd Amdt changes through the 43rd and 44th Amendments, but does not remove the duties.
2002 ยท 86th Amendment Act adds the 11th duty, (k): education for children aged 6 to 14.

๐Ÿ‡ท๐Ÿ‡บ Inspired by

The Constitution of erstwhile USSR. It said a citizen's rights are inseparable from their duties.

๐Ÿ‡ฏ๐Ÿ‡ต Only democracy with a list

Japan is perhaps the only democratic Constitution with a list of citizens' duties. USA, Canada, France, Germany, Australia have none.

๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ "Historical mistake"

The ruling Congress said leaving duties out was a historical mistake, and it was now doing what the framers failed to do.
Exam trap: Socialist countries gave equal importance to rights and duties. Major democracies (except Japan) do not list duties at all.

2Swaran Singh Committee (1976)

Suggested 8, got 10. Some ideas were dropped.

In simple words: The committee said citizens must know that along with enjoying rights, they also have duties. It asked for a separate chapter. Congress accepted the idea but not every recommendation.
Committee saidAccepted?
Add a separate chapter on Fundamental DutiesYes (Part IVA)
8 Fundamental DutiesYes, and more: 10 were added
Parliament may give penalty or punishment for not following dutiesNo
Such a penalty law cannot be challenged in court for violating FRs or any other provisionNo
Duty to pay taxes should be a Fundamental DutyNo
Memory trick for what was rejected
Punish ยท Protect the law ยท Pay tax
"3 Ps were Passed over"

3The 11 duties ยท Article 51A

"It shall be the duty of every citizen of India..."

Mnemonic (first letter of each key word, a โ†’ k)
Clever Friends Sit Down, Hug Happily, Go Study, Protect Everyone's Kids
Constitution ยท Freedom ยท Sovereignty ยท Defend ยท Harmony ยท Heritage ยท Green ยท Science ยท Property ยท Excellence ยท Kids
Nation (aโ€“d)Society (eโ€“f)Nature & mind (gโ€“i)Self & family (jโ€“k)
Then tap a letter to reveal it.
C(a)
Constitution
Abide by the Constitution and respect its ideals and institutions, the National Flag and the National Anthem.
F(b)
Freedom struggle ideals
Cherish and follow the noble ideals that inspired the national struggle for freedom.
S(c)
Sovereignty, unity, integrity
Uphold and protect the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India.
D(d)
Defend the country
Defend the country and render national service when called upon to do so.
H(e)
Harmony + dignity of women
Promote harmony and common brotherhood among all people, transcending religious, linguistic, regional or sectional diversities; renounce practices derogatory to the dignity of women.
H(f)
Heritage (composite culture)
Value and preserve the rich heritage of the country's composite culture.
G(g)
Green: environment
Protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers and wildlife, and have compassion for living creatures.
S(h)
Scientific temper
Develop scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform.
P(i)
Public property, no violence
Safeguard public property and abjure (give up) violence.
E(j)
Excellence
Strive towards excellence in all spheres of individual and collective activity so that the nation constantly rises to higher levels of endeavour and achievement.
K(k)
Kids' education (6โ€“14 yrs) 86th Amdt, 2002
Provide opportunities for education to his/her child or ward between the age of six and fourteen years.
Exam trap: Duty (k) is the only one added later (86th Amdt, 2002). It is a duty of the parent or guardian. The 42nd Amdt gave 10 duties, not 11.

4Features

4 points. Remember: Moral + civic, Indian way of life, Citizens only, Non-justiciable โ†’ "MICN"

1 ยท Moral and civic

Some are moral (cherish ideals of freedom struggle). Some are civic (respect Constitution, Flag, Anthem).

2 ยท Indian way of life

They codify values already part of Indian tradition, mythology, religions and practices.

3 ยท Citizens only

They apply to citizens only, not foreigners. Some FRs apply to foreigners too.

4 ยท Non-justiciable

Like DPSP, courts cannot directly enforce them and there is no legal sanction. But Parliament can enforce them by law.
Footnote fact: FRs available to all persons (citizens and foreigners): Articles 14, 20, 21, 21A, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28.

5Criticism

5 points. Remember "I V M S P": Incomplete, Vague, Moral only, Superfluous, Placement

  1. Incomplete list: misses voting, paying taxes, family planning. (Tax duty was even suggested by Swaran Singh Committee.)
  2. Vague: words like "noble ideals", "composite culture", "scientific temper" are hard for a common man and can be read many ways.
  3. Moral precepts only: non-justiciable, so critics call them a code of morals. (Swaran Singh had suggested penalties.)
  4. Superfluous: people would do these duties anyway, even if not written in the Constitution.
  5. Wrong place: added as an appendage to Part IV. Critics say they should come right after Part III to stand equal with Fundamental Rights.

6Significance

5 points. Remember "R W I C E": Reminder, Warning, Inspiration, Courts, Enforceable

  1. Reminder: while enjoying rights, citizens owe duties to the country, society and fellow citizens.
  2. Warning against anti-national and anti-social acts, like burning the flag or destroying public property.
  3. Inspiration: build discipline and commitment. Citizens become active participants, not mere spectators.
  4. Help Courts judge whether a law is constitutional (see cases below).
  5. Enforceable by law: Parliament can impose penalty or punishment for not fulfilling them.

โš–๏ธ Mohan Kumar Singhania vs Union of India (1991)

SC: Article 51A can be used to interpret ambiguous laws to decide their constitutionality.

โš–๏ธ Re: Ramlila Maidan Incident (2012)

A common thread runs through Parts III, IV and IVA: rights, principles of governance, duties. Read all three together when interpreting any of them.

7Who said what

For: Gokhale, Indira Gandhi ยท Against: Chawla, Daphtary, A.K. Sen

"...the provisions of chapter on fundamental duties would have a sobering effect on these restless spirits who have had a host of anti-national subversive and unconstitutional agitations in the past."H.R. Gokhale, then Law MinisterFOR ยท said a section of people showed no anxiety to respect legal order, especially on the eve of Emergency (June 1975)
"The moral value of fundamental duties would be not to smother rights but to establish a democratic balance by making the people conscious of their duties equally as they are conscious of their rights."Indira Gandhi, then Prime MinisterFOR ยท said duties would strengthen democracy
"The duties may be spelt out in a more concrete form, one is left guessing the noble ideals... Duties should be so worded as to catch the imagination of the common man."D.D. Chawla, President, National Forum of Lawyers and Legal Aid, DelhiAGAINST ยท vagueness (even "Bhagat Singh cult" could be called a noble ideal)
Over 99.9% of citizens are law-abiding. "To tell them what their duties are implies that they are not content. If that is the case after 26 years, it is not their fault."C.K. Daphtary, former Attorney GeneralAGAINST ยท superfluous
"A democratic set-up... is reduced to the position of a harsh school master asking the student to stand up on the classroom bench because he has not done the homework... The state's confidence in the citizens is obviously shaken."A.K. SenAGAINST ยท the Republic now acts as master of the people who created it
Consensus: The Opposition strongly opposed them in 1976, but the Janata Government (Morarji Desai) did not annul them. The 86th Amdt (2002) adding one more shows everyone came to accept duties.
Memory hook
School master = Sen ยท 99.9 = Daphtary ยท Sobering = Gokhale

8Verma Committee (1999)

Verma Committee on Fundamental Duties of the Citizens found laws that already enforce some duties

LawWhat it does
Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971Stops disrespect to Constitution, National Flag, National Anthem
Criminal laws (various)Punish encouraging enmity on grounds of language, race, place of birth, religion
Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955Punishes offences related to caste and religion. Called Untouchability (Offences) Act till 1976.
Indian Penal Code (IPC)Imputations and assertions prejudicial to national integration are punishable
Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967Lets a communal organisation be declared an unlawful association
Representation of People Act, 1951Disqualifies MPs/MLAs for corrupt practice: seeking votes on religion, or promoting enmity on caste, race, language, religion
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972Bans trade in rare and endangered species
Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980Checks deforestation and diversion of forest land for non-forest use
Years in order of the list
71 ยท crim ยท 55 ยท IPC ยท 67 ยท 51 ยท 72 ยท 80
Tip: two green laws come last: Wildlife 1972, Forest 1980

9One-page revision

FactAnswer
Part / ArticlePart IVA / Article 51A (only one Article)
SourceErstwhile USSR Constitution
CommitteeSardar Swaran Singh Committee, 1976 (set up by Congress Party)
Suggested vs added8 suggested โ†’ 10 added (42nd, 1976) โ†’ 11 now (86th, 2002)
11th duty(k) Education for child/ward aged 6โ€“14
Rejected ideasPenalty, no court challenge to that penalty law, duty to pay taxes
Who is boundCitizens only
Justiciable?No, but Parliament can enforce by law
CasesMohan Kumar Singhania (1991), Ramlila Maidan (2012)
Verma Committee1999, listed existing laws that enforce duties
Only democracy with duties listJapan
Did Janata Govt remove them?No (43rd 1977 and 44th 1978 undid other changes only)

10Quick MCQs

Tap an option. The answer and reason appear.

Try first, then check the answer under each question.

Score: 0 / 0
Plan this chapter in the free planner

Put Indian Polity on your day-by-day plan. UPSC Planner schedules your revisions of each chapter and tracks your hours and mock scores, so you always know if you are on track. Free to use, no sign-up needed.

Open the free planner

More free notes: all Indian Polity chapters ยท every subject ยท Read next: Fundamental Duties (Article 51A) in 5 minutes