UPSC PlannerNotesFree toolsBlogPlanner

DPSP Easy NotesLaxmikanth Ch. 9 · Part IV · Art 36–51

Directive Principles in 5 minutes

Instructions to the State on how to make laws and policies for a welfare state. Courts cannot enforce them, but the State must apply them while making laws (Art 37).

Part IVArt 36 to 51
Ireland 1937borrowed from (Ireland copied Spain)
Non-justiciableno court can enforce
Welfare statenot a police state

1 · The big idea

  • What: ideals the State keeps in mind when making policies and laws. Constitutional instructions in legislative, executive and administrative matters.
  • Art 36: "State" means the same as in Part III (FR): Centre and state legislatures and executives, all local authorities and other public authorities.
  • Art 37: not enforceable by courts, but fundamental in the governance of the country, and the State has a duty to apply them in making laws.
  • Footnote trap: the actual principles are in Art 38 to 51. Art 36 = definition, Art 37 = nature and significance.
  • Ambedkar: called them "novel features" of the Constitution, and said they are like the Instrument of Instructions of the GoI Act 1935 (issued to the Governor-General and Governors), only now addressed to the legislature and executive.
  • Granville Austin: DPSP + FR together = "Conscience of the Constitution". Together they are the philosophy and soul of the Constitution.
Remember the chain: Spain → Ireland (1937) → India. And GoI Act 1935's Instrument of Instructions is the model for the idea.

2 · Five features

  1. Ideals for the State while making policies and laws.
  2. Resemble the "Instrument of Instructions" of the GoI Act 1935.
  3. A comprehensive economic, social and political programme to realise the Preamble's justice, liberty, equality and fraternity. They aim at economic and social democracy and a welfare state.
  4. Non-justiciable: the government (Central, state, local) cannot be compelled by courts to implement them.
  5. Still useful in court: if a law gives effect to a DPSP, the court may treat it as "reasonable" under Art 14 or Art 19 and save it from being struck down.
Police state = only law and order plus defence (19th-century laissez-faire). DPSP reject this idea.

3 · Three families of DPSP

The Constitution itself does not classify them. This grouping is by content (asked a lot in Prelims).

Socialistic

Democratic socialist state, social and economic justice.

38, 39, 39A, 41, 42, 43, 43A, 47

Gandhian

Gandhi's programme of reconstruction from the national movement.

40, 43, 43B, 46, 47, 48

Liberal-intellectual

Ideology of liberalism.

44, 45, 48, 48A, 49, 50, 51
Double-entry articles. 43, 47 and 48 appear in two families because they have two parts. 43: living wage (Socialistic) and cottage industries (Gandhian). 47: nutrition and public health (Socialistic) and prohibition of liquor (Gandhian). 48: cow slaughter ban (Gandhian) and modern agriculture (Liberal).

See every article with its memory trick in the Lists tab.

4 · Amendments that added or changed DPSP

AmendmentWhat it did
42nd (1976)Added 4: Art 39(f) healthy development of children · 39A equal justice and free legal aid · 43A workers in management of industries · 48A environment, forests and wildlife
44th (1978)Added Art 38(2): minimise inequalities in income, status, facilities and opportunities
86th (2002)Changed Art 45 to early childhood care and education until age 6. Elementary education became a FR under Art 21A. (Old Art 45: free and compulsory education until age 14.)
97th (2011)Added Art 43B: voluntary formation, autonomous functioning, democratic control and professional management of co-operative societies
42nd gave India a CLEW: Children (39f) · Legal aid (39A) · Environment (48A) · Workers in management (43A)

5 · Why are they not enforceable?

Sir B.N. Rau (Constitutional Advisor) suggested splitting rights into justiciable (FR, Part III) and non-justiciable (DPSP, Part IV). The Drafting Committee accepted it.

3 reasons framers gave

  1. Not enough money (financial resources).
  2. Vast diversity and backwardness.
  3. The newborn State had many preoccupations and needed freedom to decide the order, time, place and mode.
Mnemonic: M-D-F → Money, Diversity, Freedom.

So what is the force behind them?

A moral obligation on the State, and the real force is political: public opinion. The framers trusted "awakened public opinion rather than court procedures" (M.P. Jain).

6 · Criticism (4 points)

1 No legal force
Main criticism. K.T. Shah: "pious superfluities", "cheque on a bank payable only when resources permit". Nasiruddin: "New Year's resolutions broken on 2 January". T.T. Krishnamachari: "veritable dustbin of sentiments". K.C. Wheare: "manifesto of aims and aspirations", "moral homily". Ivor Jennings: "pious aspirations".
2 Illogically arranged
N. Srinivasan: neither properly classified nor logically arranged; mixes unimportant issues with vital ones, the modern with the old, reason with sentiment. Jennings: no consistent philosophy.
3 Conservative
Ivor Jennings: based on 19th-century English philosophy. "The ghosts of Sydney and Beatrice Webb stalk through the pages." Part IV expresses "Fabian Socialism without the socialism". May be outmoded in the 21st century.
4 Constitutional conflict
K. Santhanam: may cause conflict between (a) Centre and states, (b) President and Prime Minister, (c) Governor and Chief Minister. Example: the President may reject a bill that violates DPSP.
Mnemonic: "No Illogical Conservative Conflict" → No legal force, Illogical, Conservative, Conflict.

7 · Utility (why they still matter)

M.C. Setalvad (former Attorney General): no legal rights or remedies, but useful because they:

  1. Are like an Instrument of Instructions to all authorities.
  2. Are beacon-lights to courts in judicial review.
  3. Form the dominating background to all State action.
  4. Amplify the Preamble.

Other roles

  1. Stability and continuity of policy even when the ruling party changes.
  2. Supplement FR: fill the vacuum in Part III with social and economic rights.
  3. Create a good atmosphere for enjoying FR. Political democracy without economic democracy has no meaning.
  4. Let the Opposition criticise the government.
  5. A test of government performance for the people.
  6. A common political manifesto: "guide, philosopher and friend" of every ruling party.

8 · Directives outside Part IV

335
Claims of SCs and STs to services, consistent with efficiency of administration Part XVI
350A
Instruction in mother tongue at primary stage for linguistic minority children Part XVII
351
Union's duty to spread and develop Hindi Part XVII

Also non-justiciable, but courts give them equal importance because all parts of the Constitution must be read together.

Trick: "335 Services, 350A Speak (mother tongue), 351 Swadeshi tongue (Hindi)".

9 · How DPSP were implemented

DPSP goalLaws and steps (examples)
Planning (38)Planning Commission 1950 → replaced by NITI Aayog 2015; Five Year Plans
Land reforms (39)Abolish zamindars, jagirdars, inamdars; tenancy reforms; land ceilings; surplus land to landless; co-operative farming
Labour (42, 43)Minimum Wages Act 1948, Payment of Wages 1936, Bonus 1965, Contract Labour 1970, Child Labour 1986 (renamed Child and Adolescent Labour Act in 2016), Bonded Labour Abolition 1976, Trade Unions 1926, Factories 1948, Mines 1952, Industrial Disputes 1947, Workmen's Compensation 1923; child labour banned 2006
Women (39, 42)Maternity Benefit Act 1961, Equal Remuneration Act 1976
Common good (39b, c)Life insurance nationalised 1956, 14 banks 1969, general insurance 1971, Privy Purses abolished 1971
Legal aid (39A)Legal Services Authorities Act 1987; Lok Adalats (status of a civil court, no appeal)
Cottage industries (43)KVIC, Khadi and Village Industries Board, Handloom, Coir, Silk Boards
Living standard (47)Community Development Programme 1952, IRDP 1978, JRY 1989, SGSY 1999, SGRY 2001, NREGP 2006
Environment (48A)Wildlife (Protection) Act 1972, Forest (Conservation) Act 1980, Water and Air Acts (Pollution Control Boards), National Forest Policy 1988
Panchayats (40)Three-tier panchayati raj; 73rd Amendment 1992
Weaker sections (46)Reservations; Protection of Civil Rights Act 1976 (old Untouchability Offences Act 1955); SC/ST Atrocities Act 1989; 65th Amdt 1990 NC for SCs and STs, split by 89th Amdt 2003; NCBC 1993 (constitutional status by 102nd Amdt 2018), NCM 1993, NCW 1992, NCPCR 2007; 10% EWS quota 2019 (103rd Amdt)
Judiciary (50)CrPC 1973 separated judiciary from executive
Monuments (49)Ancient and Historical Monument and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act 1951
Health (47)PHCs, hospitals; drives against malaria, TB, leprosy, AIDS etc.
Cows (48)Cow slaughter bans in some states
Old age (41)Old age pension above 65 in some states
Peace (51)Non-alignment and Panchsheel
Why not fully implemented? Lack of money, unfavourable socio-economic conditions, population explosion, strained Centre-state relations.
Plan this chapter in the free planner

Put Indian Polity on your day-by-day plan. UPSC Planner schedules your revisions of each chapter and tracks your hours and mock scores, so you always know if you are on track. Free to use, no sign-up needed.

Open the free planner

More free notes: all Indian Polity chapters · every subject · Read next: DPSP vs Fundamental Rights